Taint of Identity Politics, Political Correctness Responsible for Most Boring Super Bowl Ever?

7 More

Let’s Stop Pretending The Border Wall Was Anything More Than A Campaign Gimmick

1 More

Yes, a border wall is necessary. Here’s why.

3 More

Back-to-back injunctions ward off Trump administration’s “Final Rules,” which would allow more employers to deny workers access to birth control coverage

1 More

Truemag

  • Trump
    • Trump’s Promises
    • Trump’s Broken Promises
    • Trump’s Accomplishments
    • Trump’s Failures
    • Trump’s Tweets
    • Trumps Policies
    • Never Trumper’s
    • Fake Media
    • CNN
    • the Deep State
  • Fake Media
    • Definition
    • Types of Fake Media
    • Concerning Trump
    • Political Correctness
    • Agenda-driven Opposing thought
    • Mainstream Media
    • Problems
    • Nefarious Objectives
  • 1st & 2nd Amendment
    • Attack of the Pulpit Johnson
    • Attackers of
    • Defenders of
    • Constitutional carry
    • Freedom of Speech is NOT freedom from speech
  • Talking Heads
    • Tucker Carlson
    • Laura Ingram
    • Morning Joe
  • News Outlets
    • CNN
    • ABC
    • NBC
    • Fox News
    • Breitbart
    • Huffington Post
    • Slate
    • DiscernibleTruth
  • Career Politicians
    • Mitch McConnell
    • Hillary Clinton
    • Paul Ryan
    • Maxine Waters
    • John Cornyn
  • Things That Matter
    • Benghazi
    • IRS Abuses
    • The US Debt
    • George Soros
    • Obamacare
    • Welfare State
  • Border & Immigration
    • Sanctuary Cities
    • Costs of English as a 2nd Language
    • Lack of Assimilation
    • Associated Problems
      • Violence
      • Drugs
      • MS-13
      • Depression of wages for legal residence
  • Bare Bones
Taint of Identity Politics, Political Correctness Responsible for Most Boring Super Bowl Ever?
MJ Moye
February 14, 2019
MORE
Let’s Stop Pretending The Border Wall Was Anything More Than A Campaign Gimmick
Lynn Hauka
February 5, 2019
MORE
Yes, a border wall is necessary. Here’s why.
Steve Burns
February 5, 2019
MORE
Back-to-back injunctions ward off Trump administration’s “Final Rules,” which would allow more employers to deny workers access to birth control coverage
Walt Winters
February 5, 2019
MORE
Outraged by arrest of Huawei official, China sentences Canadian drug smuggler to death
Walt Winters
February 5, 2019
MORE
Northern Ireland’s police point fingers at “New IRA” group in Saturday night car bombing
Walt Winters
February 5, 2019
MORE
After talks with North Korean envoy, White House says Trump will hold second summit with Kim Jong-un next month
Walt Winters
February 5, 2019
MORE
Theresa May’s Brexit plan fails in record-breaking rejection by Parliament
Walt Winters
February 5, 2019
MORE
LA teachers take to the frontlines of the fight against school privatization
Walt Winters
February 4, 2019
MORE
German antitrust watchdog goes after Facebook for abuse of monopoly power and illegal data-collection practices
Walt Winters
February 4, 2019
MORE
In desperate need of U.S. dollars, Zimbabwe braces against total economic collapse
Walt Winters
February 4, 2019
MORE
Ivanka Trump will reportedly be among names submitted by the White House for the new head of the World Bank
Walt Winters
February 4, 2019
MORE
previous arrow
next arrow
Slider

Wheeler’s EPA redefines public health benefits of coal regulation, says mercury limits are “not appropriate and necessary”

The Environmental Protections Agency released a proposal on Friday that would weaken Obama-era regulations on mercury emissions from coal power, and in doing so pave the way for coal mining companies to challenge those rules in court. Perhaps more than any other of Trump’s environmental policy rollbacks so far, the specific changes made under the leadership of EPA chief Andrew Wheeler reveal the canyon between the current administration’s idea of what environmental regulation should be and that of its predecessor.

The original Mercury and Air Toxic Standards (MATS) rule, was put in place by the Obama administration in 2012 to restrict the release of mercury into the air by coal-powered plants. The cost to plants to install expensive equipment to curb mercury emissions was estimated to be between 7.4 and 9.6 billion. For the Obama-era EPA, the estimated public health benefit was 80 billion dollars a year, a figure that included the prevention of an estimated 11,000 premature deaths. The vast majority of that figure, however, was made up of what are known as co-benefits: indirect benefits of limiting mercury output like the reduction of particulate matter in the air, a known cause of heart and lung disease. In 2012, 80 billion dollars in public health benefits outweighed the smaller cost to the industry.

Wheeler’s proposed rule would ignore those co-benefits — the widespread prevention of death and disease, that is — and rewrite the cost-benefit analysis that serves as the rule’s legal justification. The new number for the cumulative public health benefits of the rule? 4 to 6 million dollars a year, or .0075 percent of the old estimate. The new rule, the agency said in a press release, “proposes to correct flaws in the [2012] Supplemental Finding and proposes to make a revised determination that it is not appropriate and necessary to regulate HAP [Hazardous Air Pollutants] emissions from coal- and oil-fired power plants.”

If implemented, the changes themselves would not erase the rule, but their drastic reevaluation of the cost-benefit analysis would make it difficult to justify the cost to the industry. In this way, the EPA would signal to the industry its opportunity to challenge the regulations in court.

Environmental activists were outraged. “This policy Andrew Wheeler and Donald Trump proposed today means more pregnant women, young children, and the elderly will be exposed to deadly neurotoxins and poisons, just so wealthy coal and oil barons can make a few extra bucks,” said the Sierra Club’s Beyond Coal Campaign Director Mary Anne Hitt. “Virtually every coal plant in the U.S. has already met this lifesaving standard, and now Trump is recklessly trying to roll it back.”

A proposal on the MATS rule has been anticipated since August, and indeed most expected the administration to downplay the public health benefits in favor of the coal industry. Because of the 40 percent decrease in coal production over the last ten years, however, and lobbying efforts on Capitol Hill to keep the rule in place, most expected the EPA to simply make it more difficult to establish new rules in the future. As a result, the extent of the revision came as something of a surprise to many, including the electric utility companies that have already invested billions meeting the new requirements with less-polluting equipement. “This is like when your four-year-old kid tries to clean up your kitchen — it actually makes things worse,” said one unnamed Washington utility lobbyist. “The rule itself forced coal plant shutdowns, but they aren’t coming back.”

In July, those same lobbying groups sent a letter to the EPA urging it to leave the rule in place. In it, they described how the industry had spent 18 billion dollars complying with the new standards, and had successfully reduced mercury emissions by nearly 90 percent since 2012.

The 2012 rule indeed ran many smaller plants out of business, who couldn’t afford to pay for the new equipment. Robert Murray, CEO of Murray Energy Corporation, became the industry stalwart after the rule’s implementation, challenging the administration in court for years and condemning the rule’s contribution to the decline of U.S. coal. Murray is also a former client of Wheeler’s, who was a lobbyist before joining the EPA.

Wheeler, however, insisted that the new proposal was solely in response to a 2015 Supreme Court decision that instructed the Obama administration to reevaluate economic costs to the industry. It did, and the rule was upheld, despite renewed legal challenges from the industry. “We don’t answer to the utility industry,” he said. “We don’t answer to the coal industry. We answer to Congress and the courts, and the Supreme Court told us we didn’t get it right. We have to redo it.” That the agency has to change the rule, however, is simply not true, because since the rule’s successful reimplementation no such court ruling has been made.

Jan 2, 2019Steve Burns
With elections on the horizon, Ukrainian president ends martial law with warnings of the ongoing threat posed by RussiaWells Fargo to pay 575 million to U.S. states in ongoing dispute over the bank’s criminal practices
You Might Also Like
 
Trump Challenges H-1B, low-wage restrictions
 
Image Post Format Without Sidebar

You must be logged in to post a comment. - Log in

Steve Burns
1 month ago In the Spotlight, Trending Issues, Uncategorized1
Most commented
Attorney General Jeff Sessions calls for 46 Obama-appointed attorney resignations
2 Comments
Trump Blamed For False Alarm Hawaiian Missile Attack?—Not so Fast!
1 Comment
NICHOLAS FREITAS SPEAKS
1 Comment
Journalism Ethics in the Spotlight
1 Comment
Taint of Identity Politics, Political Correctness Responsible for Most Boring Super Bowl Ever?
Recent Comments
  • TruthRx on Journalism Ethics in the Spotlight
  • TruthRx on NICHOLAS FREITAS SPEAKS
  • TruthRx on Trump Blamed For False Alarm Hawaiian Missile Attack?—Not so Fast!
  • TruthRx on Attorney General Jeff Sessions calls for 46 Obama-appointed attorney resignations
  • education online courses on Attorney General Jeff Sessions calls for 46 Obama-appointed attorney resignations
Footer Sidebar 1

Drop a widget on "Footer Sidebar 1" sidebar at Appearance > Widgets page.

Categories
  • 1st & 2nd Amendment (49)
  • 2016 Election (18)
  • 2nd Admendment (18)
  • Action Center (112)
  • Adverse Effects (46)
  • Agenda-driven Opposing thought (13)
  • Animal stories (1)
  • Associated Problems (4)
  • Attackers of (5)
  • Bare Bones (66)
  • Behind the Scenes (87)
  • Big Government (74)
  • Big Goverrnment (41)
  • Border & Immigration (22)
  • Breitbart (1)
  • Career Politicians (47)
  • Climate Change (1)
  • CNN (3)
  • CNN (5)
  • Coal (1)
  • Colleges and Universities in America (2)
  • Concerning Trump (12)
  • Constitutional carry (1)
  • Crime (4)
  • Debt (2)
  • Deep State (23)
  • Defenders of (5)
  • DiscernibleTruth (6)
  • Diversity (3)
  • Domestic Issues (54)
  • Drugs (2)
  • Economics (23)
  • Education in America (15)
  • Elected Officials (35)
  • Election Integrity (16)
  • Elections in the USA (1)
  • Energy Independence (2)
  • Environment (12)
  • Environmental (8)
  • EPA (2)
  • Examples of hate speech directed at opposing views (2)
  • Examples of Political agendas directing education (2)
  • Fake Media (50)
  • Fake Media (10)
  • Foreign Affairs (68)
  • Fox News (1)
  • Free Trade (2)
  • Freedom of Speech is NOT freedom from speech (20)
  • Gas and Oil Services (1)
  • George Soros (1)
  • Gun Ban (23)
  • Hate Speech (7)
  • HealthCare (7)
  • High Schools in America (2)
  • Hillary Clinton (8)
  • How Established (3)
  • In the Spotlight (230)
  • Intrusive Regulatory Control (2)
  • Islam (8)
  • Isolationists (1)
  • Israel (2)
  • Jeff Flake (1)
  • John Cornyn (1)
  • Judges (2)
  • Justice (4)
  • Lack of Assimilation (1)
  • Laura Ingram (1)
  • Legalization (1)
  • Liberalism (11)
  • Liberalism and Statism in Education (6)
  • Lies (2)
  • Like-Minded Citizens (1)
  • Mainstream Media (12)
  • Marijuana (1)
  • Maxine Waters (1)
  • Media: Bias and Agenda-driven (23)
  • Medical (1)
  • Mitch McConnell (1)
  • MS-13 (2)
  • My Professor (2)
  • National Defense (21)
  • Nefarious Objectives (14)
  • Never Trumper’s (7)
  • News Outlets (20)
  • Notable Citizens (11)
  • Nuclear (2)
  • Nursing Professionals (2)
  • Obama and his Policies (5)
  • Obamacare (3)
  • Obamacare (3)
  • Pain Patient (1)
  • Paul Ryan (1)
  • PC destroying Freedom of Speech (16)
  • Physicians: Death by Big Gov’t Bureaucratic Strangulation (1)
  • Political Correctness (6)
  • Political Correctness (12)
  • Political Thought (13)
  • Politicians: Dishonest and Manipulative (3)
  • Politics (53)
  • Privilege & Racism (7)
  • Recent findings (3)
  • Repeal (3)
  • Restaurant Industry (1)
  • Rules for Radicals and Statist (2)
  • Sanctuary Cities (3)
  • Senator Chuck Schumer (3)
  • Small Business Owners (1)
  • Social Issues (77)
  • Social Security (1)
  • Spending and Taxation (2)
  • Statism (4)
  • Suppression of free speech and opposing views (2)
  • Supreme Court (1)
  • Talking Heads (9)
  • Tariffs (2)
  • Taxes (4)
  • Term limits (3)
  • The Constitutional Statutes (4)
  • the Deep State (8)
  • The Problem Islam (1)
  • The US Debt (1)
  • Things That Matter (49)
  • Tolerance (5)
  • Trending Issues (277)
  • True Blue (5)
  • Trump (86)
  • Trump Pro-2A (3)
  • Trump's Administration (55)
  • Trump's Promises (11)
  • Trump’s Accomplishments (14)
  • Trump’s Failures (1)
  • Trump’s Tweets (3)
  • Trumps Policies (11)
  • Types of Fake Media (3)
  • Ultimate sacrifice (1)
  • Uncategorized (485)
  • United Nations (4)
  • Violence (2)
  • White Privilege (3)
  • women & children defending themselves (1)
Archives
  • February 2019 (15)
  • January 2019 (8)
  • December 2018 (52)
  • November 2018 (58)
  • October 2018 (52)
  • September 2018 (39)
  • August 2018 (61)
  • July 2018 (50)
  • June 2018 (33)
  • May 2018 (23)
  • April 2018 (23)
  • March 2018 (24)
  • February 2018 (10)
  • January 2018 (18)
  • December 2017 (11)
  • November 2017 (14)
  • October 2017 (19)
  • September 2017 (6)
  • August 2017 (1)
  • June 2017 (10)
  • May 2017 (1)
  • April 2017 (5)
  • March 2017 (3)
  • January 2017 (1)
  • May 2016 (8)
  • April 2014 (1)
  • December 2013 (10)
  • November 2013 (5)
  • October 2013 (7)
  • September 2013 (5)
Email-Subscription

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest news and event postings.

2019 © Welcome to Discernible Truth